Contested ESI Protocol Denied Where the Federal Rules Adequately Address the Case's ESI Needs

Halle v. Jansen, No. 3:25-cv-1754-JPG (S.D. Ill. Nov. 13, 2026), full opinion (PDF)

A self-represented plaintiff sued police officers over a traffic stop that they partly recorded on camera. He moved for entry of an ESI protocol over the officers' opposition. A federal court in the Southern District of Illinois denied the motion. Absent a stipulation, the court explained, the party seeking a protocol bears the burden of showing good cause, a specific reason the case needs one. The court concluded that the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure adequately addressed the case's needs for ESI discovery. A movant seeking a contested protocol therefore has to identify a need the existing rules leave unaddressed.

What happened

The plaintiff's proposed protocol addressed the preservation and identification of relevant ESI. It would also have required production in native format with metadata maintained. The court noted that the motion did not explain why the case needed a protocol. Earlier, however, the plaintiff had told the court of his concerns about the upkeep of the ESI, including metadata, and his access to that data.

According to the officers, their department stores its camera footage on a cloud-based system run by Axon. They represented that the system keeps audit trails logging every action taken on a file, revisions included. The officers further stated that they had no objection to producing original copies of the relevant videos in their possession, each with its corresponding audit trail.

The court's analysis

The court concluded that the plaintiff could achieve his goals for preservation and production format without a protocol. On format, it pointed to Rule 34(b)(1)(C), which lets a requesting party specify the form in which ESI is to be produced. On preservation, it relied on the officers' representations about the audit trails. The court reasoned that the plaintiff would be able to determine whether any produced video had been edited. It added that he could subpoena Axon if necessary.

The court noted that the plaintiff had filed no reply addressing the officers' objections. Ruling on the record before it, the court denied the motion without prejudice, in an order that also resolved a separate, non-ESI motion to amend the complaint.

Why it matters

Before moving for a contested protocol, a movant should put the case-specific need in the motion. Because Rule 34(b)(1)(C) lets the requester specify the form of production, a wish for native files with metadata is unlikely to justify a protocol on its own.

For the responding party, explaining how its systems preserve and log the ESI at issue gives the court a concrete reason to find a protocol unnecessary. An offer to produce originals with their change logs makes that explanation more persuasive.

A reply is the movant's chance to answer the opponent's account of its systems. A movant who files none leaves that account unanswered when the court rules.

The full opinion is available as a PDF.

Related cases

ESI ProtocolSampling Has to Look for a Miss the Protocol Does Not Already CatchIn re Class Action Settlement Admin. Litig. · D.D.C. · August 19, 2026ESI ProtocolAn ESI Protocol's Search-Term Provision Did Not Cap the Producing Party's Duty to Search EmailCR Legal Team, LLP v. Carruthers & Roth, P.A. · M.D.N.C. · October 20, 2026ESI ProtocolCourt Requires Rule 26(f) Disclosure of Acquired Legacy Systems and BYOD Policies, Not Volume EstimatesIn re Class Action Settlement Administration Litigation · D.D.C. · October 5, 2026

Blog › eDiscovery Case in Focus